Sintel, the Durian Open Movie Project » Blog Archive » Sintel the logo!

    

Sintel the logo!

on May 6th, 2010, by Ton

Hi all,

We’re very proud to present Sintel’s movie logo, created by designer Nick Bueltge! We will work with him on a couple of minor tweaks, like for usage in the various cases on shirts, in the film, and for the dvd.

Making this choice wasn’t simple, there were a lot of good proposals. Personally I liked his design for his elegant and very professional styling. The text and logo are slightly feminine and spiritual, which reflects in the film.

Additional good news: trailer is nearly finished… we keep fighting all kinds of nasty technical issues. It’s good on one hand – it improves blender – but it’s also frustrating… hopefully we have it in the weekend for you! We’ll also blog about every detail in making it. :)

For everyone who submitted work: THANKS SO MUCH FOR THE DESIGNS, YOU ALL ROCK!

Here’s the thread with all design proposals.

-Ton-

97 Responses to “Sintel the logo!”

  1. Elubie Says:

    Great choice, there were quite a few other nice ones too though.

    Looking forward so much to the trailer, you guys rock!

  2. stenosis Says:

    well… could be better but hopefully the movie will rock more than this logo.

  3. Davis Says:

    Looks good, I suppose the best choice would be made by the people that know what actually happens in the film.

    Waiting for the trailer… :D

  4. tyrant monkey Says:

    I remember picking that one out as a winner, it simple elegant and very readable good choice.

  5. Malcolm Zaloon Says:

    hi. i like the logo, but i thing this unbalanced.
    the top leaves need be bigger than the trunk.

  6. David Says:

    I have to say meh…

    It looks noobish compared to the ‘big buck bunny’ one.

    Cant wait to see the trailer!

  7. wo262 Says:

    yep. this is the good one

  8. wo262 Says:

    now you have to change blog’s design

  9. suryara Says:

    Well..Definitely would not be my first choice. :D

  10. ScottKelly Says:

    congrats nick! great logo!

  11. lifeling Says:

    Nice work every one! I love the efforts going into this film! Keep up the good work. Nice choice on the logo as well.

  12. wormwood Says:

    Too much tracking.
    The S is weak.
    The T is ugly.
    The crossbar of the E is too straight and clean.
    The canopy of the tree is lost.
    The underline adds nothing.
    Too similar to Avatar.

  13. umfk Says:

    The best one won. Like someone else wrote the balancing on the tree could be improved the crown is a bit flat.

  14. loopDuplicate Says:

    I really like it. It’s like it’s rubber stamped or something. Rough around the edges. Like the character models.

  15. Claus Says:

    I agree with wormwood. And it does looks noobish.
    The S should be more curly and defined.
    The bottom end of the T is makes it sloppy.
    The trunk of the tree catches your eye to much and is not in balance with the crown’s detail.
    But of course it’s too easy to criticize, and make nothing myself, so… :)

  16. wo262 Says:

    where can i report a bug from the render branch? i’d like to report it in the tracker but it is not from main trunk

  17. blenderman345 Says:

    Verry Lord-of-the-Ringsish.
    I like.
    To all of you guys critiquing the balance of text, and the leaves and trees:
    that’s intentional. Medieval, Fantasy, etc. always look like that. LOTOTR anyone? If you’ve read the books, you know.

  18. Angel Says:

    mmmmmm

  19. hector Says:

    Lo que mas me gusta de todo esto es que SINTEL se hace con muchas ganas y también… por amor al arte.

  20. Simon Says:

    I would have chosen another one, not that this one is bad, just that I thought there were one or two better. But you know your movie best, and what logo suits it.

    wo262:
    the reason the render branch is a separate branch is so other people won’t report bugs :P It is not supposed to ready for everyone yet.

  21. crowline Says:

    also gotta agree with the most of the negative comments here.

    The whole design, rather than being a simple design with some visual punch/cohesion, just seems bland and inconsistent to me. Dont dig the edge quality either. Not that it’s *bad*… im just surprised that this entry was chosen.

  22. wo262 Says:

    @Simon i read somewhere that we need to contact with renderbranch developers for report bugs directy to them.

  23. nightfury Says:

    Tree of Gondor?

  24. Consideringthepickle Says:

    I love it! I saw this one while looking over the contest thread the other day and thought this one stood out from the others. There were a lot of great submissions though, but I really like this one. Great job Nick!

  25. ziwon Says:

    don’t like the voice,
    don’t like the logo*,
    i fear i’ll don’t like the movie in the end :O

    but well… you can’t make everyone happy. and i’m still happy with big buck bunny :D
    I’m looking forward to the trailer, maybe it will make me a little bit happier then i am at the moment ^^

    *It’s not bad, but it’s really not my first choice

  26. JW Says:

    Seriously about this logo winning? Just a poorly designed Papyrus-like font. Not particularly a logo that has been hit with the original stick.

  27. J. Says:

    Simple, but it does the trick very well! :D

  28. Martín Eschoyez Says:

    Too much tracking.
    The S is weak.
    The T is ugly.
    The crossbar of the E is too straight and clean.
    The canopy of the tree is lost.
    The underline adds nothing.

    +1

    my owns proposals needs more tweaking too, by the way.

  29. stenosis Says:

    when will the trailer be out, is there a date to be target on?

  30. Deevad Says:

    I disagree with mostly of ‘against’ comments : this typo not look like Avatar or LOTR, and is not noobish or a “poorly designed Papyrus-like font” to quote last message… Thanks for those who like it and express it.

    You have to trust us we made the best choice in regards of the movie. Cause this one have an harmony feeling that reflect the movie as Ton explained on the post. ;)

    Btw, the picture Ton posted in this post is a hack I did over a little picture from Nick Bueltge ( the blue logo over the mountains ) cause I didn’t get the vector file to do my presentation at the Comicon in Naples : I enlarged / desaturated / blured / and tweaked the curves to contrast the best… An old trick to enlarge a little black and white logo without having stairs of pixels. The side effect is the loose of some dynamics and some roundish corners. So, the final logo will surely look better. But generally this one give the main idea.

  31. Gianmichele Says:

    I think it is really cool. All the other versions to me were too busy.

    Less is more and this one is a great mix of elegance and clarity.

    Can’t wait to see the trailer :D

  32. wo262 Says:

    @Deevad http://www.nick-bueltge.de/sintel/images/a_13.jpg
    http://www.nick-bueltge.de/sintel/

  33. Valentijn Says:

    Hey,
    Congrats, I thought so that this one could be the one, it stands out among the others, it’s simple and a very safe one…
    You can’t go wrong with this one

  34. Deevad Says:

    @wo262 :
    Thanks for the links ;)

  35. Angel Says:

    I want to see it on top of website.

  36. Creativeking Says:

    i can’t believe you guys chose this one. I think there were two great ones amongst the ones i saw. I definitely wouldn’t have gone for this one, but heh, u guys are the ones choosing!

  37. tobin Says:

    The font is herculanum i do believe.

    I like it, It’s a bit generic, but i think thats a good thing. and normally im not fond of herculanum in caps, reminds me of bad chinese menus and avatar though sintel written in herculanum doesn’t look like avatar so i wouldnt be worried about that (avatar isn’t in herculanum anyway – something a bit less ornate), but in fairness i used a modified papyrus! a good design is one that works and looks good, not one that has so and so font!

    Congrats Nick!

  38. MartianR Says:

    From a subjective point of view, I get the woodcut thing but I’m personally not that keen on it. Fair enough, each to their own. From a technical angle however, I think the kerning needs a little attention. The S and the T would benefit from a little bit more refinement too, so that they feel as though they are from the same font family. Criticism meant in a constructive spirit.

  39. MartianR Says:

    Although this is a strict cut from the lower case version of the Herculaneum family, it may need a tiny bit of ‘bending’ to balance out as a self-contained logo. It’s the ‘s’ that feels a little diminished. May not need much, but might make the difference.

  40. Jon Says:

    Deevad, how can you seriously say “this typo not look like Avatar” ?

    I may not be identical to Avatar’s logotype set in Papyrus, but it certainly shares a very similar aesthetic, which is made all the more so by being all in capitals and with loose letter spacing.

    The font is Monotype’s version of Herculanum by Adrian Frutiger. Unmodified.

  41. Martín Eschoyez Says:

    i really liked the first version of nick’s proposals.
    But, i think that you’re right with the selection; only the team knows what the movie reflect.
    Now i want to see the chosen one in a tee, or in the movie trailer…

    ps: Congrats to Nick!!

  42. Dylan McCall Says:

    “I may not be identical to Avatar’s logotype set in Papyrus, but it certainly shares a very similar aesthetic, which is made all the more so by being all in capitals and with loose letter spacing.”

    I’m really not seeing that:
    http://img192.imageshack.us/img192/3475/avatarsintellogo.png

    I guess they both have 6 letters in the name, and T in the middle, and a serify thing going on, but I find them very distinct from each other.

  43. Johnyman Says:

    I think it fits the film well. I was surprised at the amount and quality of submissions, great job everyone, and congrats Nick!

  44. Markus Says:

    Was not trajan the movie font? Did we had any entries with trajan font? Anyway if the creators of the movie like it I trust in there decisions. They know best was is needed on the end. I guess there were a lot of good designs and I’m sure it was not easy…

    Regards,
    Markus

  45. kenden Says:

    Congrats!
    The level of the entries was impressive.
    I also like the use of the dragon wing on another one of Nick’s picture:
    http://www.nick-bueltge.de/sintel/images/a_06.jpg
    I hope the concept gets used in the posters!

  46. Billy Says:

    Having looked through all of the logo submissions, I’m curious which logo the people who don’t like this one prefer. I saw very few that could compete.

  47. Another Fellow Says:

    I like this one, because I can actually read what it says…

  48. worthless comment Says:

    I see a viking ship and a tree. I am afraid I don’t get it, not that it matters.

  49. Another Fellow Says:

    wait, which avatar?
    http://avatarthelastairbenderepisodes.info/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/avatarlogo.jpg

    http://newteevee.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/avatar-movie-poster.jpg

  50. margreet Says:

    it is so beautiful! well done!

  51. OneEyedOdin Says:

    I really liked this logo. It has a nice primitive look to it, which I believe will fit the final movie.

  52. kram1032 Says:

    Ok, that definitely was one of the best :D
    And I guess, you know, what you do, as you know the whole movie, already. :)

  53. Lucidor Says:

    It’s a good one, but shouldn’t there at least be a hint that there is a canopy on top? To me it looks like a dead tree now.

  54. Lucidor Says:

    Maybe foliage is a better word

  55. Agus Says:

    Oh no, too bad! this is the right one:

    http://img707.imageshack.us/img707/9505/sintel.png
    (top left one)

  56. Pablo Lizardo Says:

    good work nick!
    congratulations!!!!

  57. Socceroos Says:

    I happen to absolutely love Nick’s submission! Congratulations mate!

  58. D Says:

    I think the logo fits, and I like to think it’s because I have a better feel for the movie and its tone than others. :P

  59. D Says:

    Oh, I forgot to add, OMFGOORAH! Trailer on the weekend!!!!! :D

  60. ITrAB Says:

    Cant wait for trailer! It’ll be awesome ;)

  61. RH2 Says:

    I like the text…
    nice simple and readable.

    I really dislike the tree.

  62. Eddie Says:

    Congratulations Nick!^^ – for me as long as simple and readable it’s just a-OK (i’m second that -^0^), i hope the “tweak” that you mean is for the tree, somehow i feel a hollow,emptyness and uncomplete in there,
    now trailer’s time! ^0^ (dont forget links for the slow internet speed plz)

  63. crowline Says:

    Doesn’t look like avatar? Man I must be missing something. When I sit back and squint at this image – as one does to evaluate these types of things …

    http://img192.imageshack.us/img192/3475/avatarsintellogo.png

    The similarity in aesthetic seems punch you in the face obvious. I don’t really have a problem with that… its just weird that some see it and some don’t I guess.

    Oh, and yah, high excitement for the trailer!

  64. 3dementia Says:

    because this thread has not enough comments, I second this emotion. The logo……..Rocks. Almost as hard as Durian and the Blender Foundation + Ton.

  65. Rob Cozzens Says:

    Wow. There’s a lot of negativity here! Almost makes me glad mine wasn’t chosen.

    Congrats Nick. That’s awesome.

  66. ramon miranda Says:

    reminds me a lot Avatar movie logo on tipography , but is readable. Congrats nick.i have to see integrated on the movie

  67. Ruddy Says:

    Congratulations!

  68. untel Says:

    Nice. But I’m a little disturbed by the too obvious symmetry of the tree.
    Maybe something can be done to break it a little bit?

  69. DrD Says:

    I like it. The font looks sanskrit inspired. I am surprised at the amount of negative feedback about this..

  70. Bao2 Says:

    I agree in breaking the symmetry on the tree in the upper part.
    Great logo.

  71. tino Says:

    Congrats Nick.
    Competition was fun
    Maybe some of the crits can be looked into, especially the constructive ones

    Otherwise, the team ultimately knows the story they want to tell, and the design that moves them the best should be trusted to be the right design.

  72. tino Says:

    I must agree the font does resemble the Avatar one though.

    though it shouldnt matter, right?

  73. nawabz Says:

    Actually come to think of it.. it look great on the t-shirt from that link.
    imagin how it will be on the trailer.
    it goes without saying that the rest of the logos were amazing and must have gaven the durian team a hard time when choosing best one.

    im excited and cant wait…..

  74. Cerebro Says:

    The emblem looks like a mushroom cloud. Is this movie about nuclear war?

  75. Keen Says:

    Not my first choice… but it looks great.

  76. Hubberthus Says:

    Definitely a wrong choice, it reminds me of a logo, and those things resemble letters, and if I look closely the upper part is like a tree. There are logos, letters and trees in many movies, can’t you be more creative?
    *sarcasm off*

    Who cares of Avatar? Sintel will rock! :)
    And yes, I also like the logo, congrats Nick!

  77. tino Says:

    you had some good designs there, nick http://www.nick-bueltge.de/sintel/

  78. ScottKelly Says:

    Wow I can’t believe all this negativity. Makes me wonder if they could have done a better job ;) and on the avatar thing, the fonts are similar but its not like someone will glance at it quick and think avatar. In my thoughts the tree does look a bit too symmetrical, and that could use a bit of tweaking, but other than that great job. The right one was definitely picked.

  79. Shinobi Says:

    Congratulations nick, it’s a nice logo.
    My only critic is about the tree, is not so good.. I mean, it lacks foliage!? Where are the leaves gone?
    But I think you could have done that to break the horrible tree resemblance with the nuclear mushroom it originally has…

    From Deevad:
    “Btw, the picture Ton posted in this post is a hack I did over a little picture from Nick Bueltge ( the blue logo over the mountains ) cause I didn’t get the vector file to do my presentation at the Comicon in Naples ”

    Are you serious?!
    Have you guys really choosen the logo before april the 30?! And let another week logo submission?

    And about your conference in Naples, can we see a video of the event? I’ve searched the web but I found nothing as for now…
    Thanks :)

  80. dave76 Says:

    Hi – thanks a lot for your positive feedback – very nice to read. I’ll keep on working on it in detail – bringing it to a strong, spiritual and functional final version. Once again – thanks :)

    Best regards, Nick

  81. Joey Says:

    Looks good!

    That one also got my eye from all the submissions.

    The sintel logo should be a little more extravagant imho though

  82. john lennon Says:

    enter the blog’s COLOSSUS 3D we’re making a feature film with the blender ….. the blog is: http://colossus3d.blogspot.com/

  83. Simon Says:

    I like this:
    SVN commit 3060: Credits for the trailer. (colin)

  84. vangelis Says:

    Where ‘s the trailer ?

    Why not Debian Stable instead of Ubuntu ? :(

  85. nawabz Says:

    oh yh the new Ubuntu lucis lynx 10.04 lts is out. better have blender already installed.

  86. AlesWolf Says:

    Good choice!!

    (tree of Gondor…xD)

  87. weilynncg Says:

    Congratulations Nick and The Blender Team. Actually I would have chosen the same as you guys, this one was my prefer, simple but strong.
    :)

  88. Deevad Says:

    @shinobi :
    “Are you serious?!
    Have you guys really choosen the logo before april the 30?! And let another week logo submission?”

    Hi Shinobi :) Not really ‘choosen’ at this date. During my conferences at Comicon it was only the one I choose personally to have a good look in my presentation.
    I’m glad the team was also happy with my personal choice a week after.
    For the video of the event, still have no news. Surely soon :)

  89. mmz Says:

    Actually I guess which logo they (or the community) would have chosen – the comments would be pretty much the same – because it is very natural that (of a big number of people) some like it an some don’t.
    OMG … can’t wait for the trailer anymore…it will be SO awesome

  90. Limvot Says:

    I really like it, and good job to Nick! Don’t let the haters get to you. I do agree about the canopy/leaves being a bit small, but really great, clean design over all. Great job!

  91. RH2 Says:

    I hate the tree…. who’s idea was it to put that in the logo anyways?!

    Here is a (much)better version:
    http://www.pasteall.org/pic/show.php?id=3187

    The simple text can stay, I like it being readable.

  92. RH2 Says:

    thanks to wdesigner_br for inspiring me.

    my proposed image is a derivative of this one
    http://img52.imageshack.us/img52/4802/ideia02.jpg

  93. Shinobi Says:

    Thank you, Deevad, keep us informed about conference videos ;)

  94. Wray Bowling Says:

    Sintel the lunch box!
    Sintel the coloring book!
    Sintel the flame thrower!

  95. aeres Says:

    I too don’t get the tree thingy…I gathered it is a story about Sintel looking for her pet dragon no? The logo does invoke a medieval fantasy vibe, but unless there is an important flora that figures into the story, otherwise my humble opinion is that it does not fit, thematically speaking.

    That is of course just my 2 cents and let me say you guys are doing a superb job!

  96. Luís Hansen Says:

    Really, it’s too much Avatar! It wouldn’t work!

  97. Temitopa.A Says:

    The tree is a symbol in the film, i think of the city or something similar. Yes there is no important flora in the film, according to what we know, but the symbol occours various times

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.